Item Details

Lowest-Priced Security Not Good Enough for War-Zone Embassies [electronic resource]

Commission on Wartime Contracting in Iraq and Afghanistan
Format
EBook; Book; Government Document; Online
Published
Arlington, VA : Commission on Wartime Contracting in Iraq and Afghanistan, [2009]
Language
English
Variant Title
Lowest-priced security not good enough for war zone embassies
At head of title: Special report on embassy security contracts
Series
CWC Special Report
SuDoc Number
Y 3.2:SE 2
Summary
Unlike other federal agencies, the U.S. Department of State is forbidden by law to select anything but the lowest price and "technically acceptable" offer when awarding contracts to protect its overseas buidlings--even if this means passing up offers from firms offering higher quality and better experience. In contengency operations like those in Iraq and Afghanistan, this prohibition can have negative consequences for seucrity, wartime mission objectives, and American's image. The Commission recommends removing this lowest-price restriction so that State Department contracting officers can--like their counterparts in other government agencies--use their professional judgment to select from the entire continuum of "best value" criteria and make appropriate trade-offs between cost or price and other relevant factors. When American lives and American interests are at stake, quality and experience must be considered along with price. The Commission on Wartime Contracting in Iraq and Afghanistan reached this conclusion based on research, travel to Afghanistan, and its September 14, 2009, hearing that focused on recent allegations of misconduct among employees of the State Department's contractor, ArmorGroup North America (AGNA). AGNA, a unit of Wackenhut Services, Inc., contracted to protect the U.S. Embassy and personnel in Kabul, Afghanistan. The company attracted intense media scrutiny when a watchdog group released photos showing AGNA employees in alcoholfueled acts of sexual misconduct and degradation of subordinate staff.
Description
1 online resource (6 p) : ill.
Notes
  • Title from title screen (viewed on June 22, 2011).
  • "October 1, 2009."
  • Includes bibliographical references.
Series Statement
CWC special report ; 2
Logo for Copyright Not EvaluatedCopyright Not Evaluated
Technical Details
  • Access in Virgo Classic

  • LEADER 03430nam a2200481Ia 4500
    001 u5406664
    003 SIRSI
    005 20110726153041.0
    006 m d f
    007 cr bn|||||||||
    008 091023s2009 dcua ob f000 0 eng d
    035
      
      
    a| (OCoLC)458558513
    040
      
      
    a| DOS c| DOS d| GPO d| MvI
    043
      
      
    a| n-us--- a| a-iq--- a| a-af---
    049
      
      
    a| VAL
    050
      
    4
    a| JZ1480.A5 b| L69 2009eb
    074
      
      
    a| 1089 (online)
    086
    0
      
    a| Y 3.2:SE 2
    245
    0
    0
    a| Lowest-priced security not good enough for war-zone embassies h| [electronic resource] / c| Commission on Wartime Contracting in Iraq and Afghanistan.
    246
    3
      
    a| Lowest-priced security not good enough for war zone embassies
    246
    1
      
    i| At head of title: a| Special report on embassy security contracts
    260
      
      
    a| Arlington, VA : b| Commission on Wartime Contracting in Iraq and Afghanistan, c| [2009]
    300
      
      
    a| 1 online resource (6 p) : b| ill.
    490
    1
      
    a| CWC special report ; v| 2
    500
      
      
    a| Title from title screen (viewed on June 22, 2011).
    500
      
      
    a| "October 1, 2009."
    504
      
      
    a| Includes bibliographical references.
    520
      
      
    a| Unlike other federal agencies, the U.S. Department of State is forbidden by law to select anything but the lowest price and "technically acceptable" offer when awarding contracts to protect its overseas buidlings--even if this means passing up offers from firms offering higher quality and better experience. In contengency operations like those in Iraq and Afghanistan, this prohibition can have negative consequences for seucrity, wartime mission objectives, and American's image. The Commission recommends removing this lowest-price restriction so that State Department contracting officers can--like their counterparts in other government agencies--use their professional judgment to select from the entire continuum of "best value" criteria and make appropriate trade-offs between cost or price and other relevant factors. When American lives and American interests are at stake, quality and experience must be considered along with price. The Commission on Wartime Contracting in Iraq and Afghanistan reached this conclusion based on research, travel to Afghanistan, and its September 14, 2009, hearing that focused on recent allegations of misconduct among employees of the State Department's contractor, ArmorGroup North America (AGNA). AGNA, a unit of Wackenhut Services, Inc., contracted to protect the U.S. Embassy and personnel in Kabul, Afghanistan. The company attracted intense media scrutiny when a watchdog group released photos showing AGNA employees in alcoholfueled acts of sexual misconduct and degradation of subordinate staff.
    650
      
    0
    a| Embassy buildings x| Security measures z| Afghanistan.
    650
      
    0
    a| Embassy buildings x| Security measures z| Iraq.
    650
      
    0
    a| Contracting out z| United States x| Evaluation.
    610
    1
    0
    a| United States. b| Department of State v| Rules and practice.
    650
      
    0
    a| Private security services z| United States.
    610
    2
    0
    a| ArmorGroup North America.
    650
      
    0
    a| Afghan War, 2001- z| United States.
    650
      
    0
    a| Iraq War, 2003-2011
    710
    2
      
    a| Commission on Wartime Contracting in Iraq and Afghanistan (U.S.)
    830
      
    0
    a| CWC special report ; v| 2.
    856
    4
    0
    u| http://purl.fdlp.gov/GPO/gpo8826
    596
      
      
    a| 1
    999
      
      
    a| Y 3.2:SE 2 w| SUDOC i| 5406664-1001 l| INTERNET m| UVA-LIB t| INTERNET

Availability

Google Preview

Read Online